A few weeks ago, I was given a promo code on Kobo for having been a customer for a year. I searched for interesting juvenile fiction, and came across A Different Me by Deborah Blumenthal (Albert Whitman & Company, 2014). The synopsis sounded interesting, so I decided to buy the book, and finished it within a week.
Allie Johnston’s secret wish since the day she was twelve is to have her nose done. But she hasn’t told anyone – not her parents, or even her best friend, Jen. But when she starts visiting a plastic surgery discussion board on the Web, she finds people who get her, for the first time in her life. Her new friends, including two girls her age with vastly different backgrounds who share her obsession with changing their faces—but for very different reasons. A sharply written, insightful book about learning to be happy with who we are.
For the most part, I liked this book. Most characters are really formed, though on the surface they may come across a bit superficial. That’s the whole point of the book I believe: even if a person may seem shallow, often you don’t see what’sinside of their minds unless you really attempt to get to know them. For example, Amber, the most goodlooking girl in the school, has a hidden life of pain that Allie doesn’t get to find out until she looks beyond Amber’s outward appearance.
The character of Allie herself seems to have deliberately been developed to seem a bit boring. Unlike Amber and some other characters, she doesn’t have much drama in her life. All she has is a screwed body image. This again serves the point of the book well: Allie may have a bump on her nose, but overall she has a pretty good life.
The book’s ending in terms of Allie’s nose surgery (which she ends up canceling at the last moment) is quite predictable. However, it’s not whether she has surgery that makes this book interesting, but the mental processes leading up to her decision. In this sense, I was more interested in learning about the other characters than I was in learning about Allie. After all, it’s the other characters who teach Allie that it’s not her looks that make her who she is.